Compare/GPT-4o (May '24) vs Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)

GPT-4o (May '24)vsClaude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)

Side-by-side comparison of pricing, 12 benchmarks, and generation speed.

OpenAI

GPT-4o (May '24)

Input
$5/M
Output
$15/M
Speed
78 tok/s
TTFT
0.54s
Anthropic

Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)

Input
$3/M
Output
$15/M
Speed
50 tok/s
TTFT
1.21s

Winner by Category

Cheaper
Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)
Faster (tok/s)
GPT-4o (May '24)
Lower Latency
GPT-4o (May '24)
Benchmarks (3-7)
Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)

Pricing Comparison

MetricGPT-4o (May '24)Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)
Input ($/M tokens)$5$3
Output ($/M tokens)$15$15
Cost for 1M input + 100K output tokens:
GPT-4o (May '24)$6.50
Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)$4.50

Speed Comparison

Output Speed (tokens/s) — higher is better
GPT-4o (May '24)
78 tok/s
Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)
50 tok/s
Time to First Token (seconds) — lower is better
GPT-4o (May '24)
0.54s
Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)
1.21s

Benchmark Comparison

Data from Artificial Analysis API — 12 benchmarks

Intelligence Index
14.544.4
Coding Index
24.246.4
Math Index
GPQA Diamond
52.6%79.9%
MMLU-Pro
74.0%
LiveCodeBench
33.4%
AIME 2025
MATH-500
79.1%
Humanity's Last Exam
2.8%13.2%
SciCode
30.9%46.9%
IFBench
41.2%
TerminalBench
46.2%
GPT-4o (May '24)3 wins
7 winsClaude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper, GPT-4o (May '24) or Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)?

Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort) is cheaper overall. Its blended price (3:1 input/output ratio) is $6.00/M tokens vs $7.50/M for GPT-4o (May '24).

Which model performs better on benchmarks?

Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort) wins 7 out of 12 benchmarks compared to 3 for GPT-4o (May '24). See the detailed benchmark chart above for per-category results.

Which is faster for real-time applications?

GPT-4o (May '24) generates tokens faster at 78 tok/s vs 50 tok/s. GPT-4o (May '24) also has lower time-to-first-token (0.54s vs 1.21s).

When should I use GPT-4o (May '24) vs Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort)?

Choose based on your priorities: Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort) for lower cost, Claude Sonnet 4.6 (Non-reasoning, High Effort) for stronger benchmark performance, and GPT-4o (May '24) for faster generation. For latency-sensitive apps, check the TTFT comparison above.